Conserve Utah Valley hosted a town hall meeting to help residents understand the development process in Provo City, featuring guests: Bill Peperone, Director of Development Services and Rachel Breen, Community Relations Analyst for City Council. The meeting focused on explaining how development projects move through the city’s approval process, including general plan amendments, zone changes, concept plans, development agreements, project plan reviews, and final approvals, while also covering how citizens can engage at various stages through neighborhood district meetings, Planning Commission hearings, and City Council public comment periods. Participants asked questions about material changes to projects, enforcement of development agreements, when projects might be considered regional versus local in scope, and the process for selling city-owned land as part of developments. The discussion included specific examples from the Vesper Amphitheater development project that has been ongoing in Provo, though the meeting emphasized learning the general process.

 

Watch the full recording below or using this link:

 

Below are questions that were unable to be asked during the Town Hall that were later answered by Bill Peperone:

1. Once a zoning change is approved does the council or mayor have any influence on the project plan process?

The mayor has influence because she is over the administration and project plan approval is an administrative process. The council’s influence is with decisions prior to the project plan.

2. The purpose of the OSPR Zone is to preserve public lands for recreation, education, scenic enjoyment, and future generations. If approximately 75 acres of City-owned open space are removed from that purpose, what land will replace it? If replacement is planned, how will the City determine that the replacement provides equal or greater public value?

A land trade may be offered as part of the acquisition of the 75 acres. Additionally, it is anticipated that either half of the 75 acres would be placed in a conservation easement, or half of the land would be retained by the city. The goal is to have a net increase in open space between a land exchange and open space or ownership of half the 75 acres. My recollection is the 75 acres were zoned OSPR while George Handley was on the council. However, our system of governance will not allow one city council to perpetually bind all future councils, particularly with a tool like zoning. If land is intended to remain open, it should be placed in a conservation easement held by a third party outside the city so that future councils could not unilaterally repeal the easement.

3. Many development agreements rely on discretionary words such as “may” instead of mandatory terms such as “shall.” What is the City’s reasoning for using permissive language when addressing developer obligations, particularly for environmental restoration, infrastructure completion, and long-term maintenance?

Staff, including the city attorney’s office, have helped to craft the development agreement. Staff are satisfied that the use of the word “may” is appropriate and is actually advantageous to the city in many cases. For example, future laws may be enacted by the city that would be applicable to the Project. Also, the developer must comply with the city’s hillside development standards and may not disturb any slope greater than 30%. The DA has evolved significantly since the Planning Commission meeting to give greater assurance to compliance with specific provisions. The city council has yet to review the DA.

4. If the project is abandoned, becomes financially insolvent, or is never completed, what legally enforceable provisions require the developer to restore the property? What specific obligations are mandatory, and what financial guarantees exist to ensure taxpayers are not left responsible for cleanup, demolition, environmental restoration, or maintenance?

This is a great question and one that we approach with deep caution. Typically, with land development, construction does not begin until financing has been arranged to complete the project, including bonding to guarantee completion of necessary infrastructure. While taking back city property is not anticipated, it is wise to prepare for that scenario, which is why this scenario is addressed in the DA. Restoration has not been discussed previously, which is why I would anticipate further changes and additions to the development agreement after the August 11 council work session. Restoration could be included in the improvement bonds I referred to last night but that would have to be added to the DA or documented some other way.

5. When does a project stop being “Provo’s project” and become a regional project? For a development expected to affect traffic, public safety, infrastructure, and recreation well beyond the City’s boundaries, what objective thresholds require Provo City to actively coordinate with UDOT, MAG, Utah County, Wasatch County, neighboring municipalities, and other affected agencies? More importantly, does that coordination occur early enough to influence the project, or only after key decisions have already been made?

Orem City, Utah County, and UDOT have already been involved in Vesper discussions because the city recognizes the regional impacts that could stem from this project. UDOT approval is prerequisite to project plan approval. UDOT takes into consideration MAG’s traffic projections and regional transportation patterns and impacts. For example, development occurring in Heber and Wasatch County impacts Provo Canyon and the 800 N University interchange. The improvements UDOT will require to the road, and the interchange, will improve existing conditions and will consider maximum amphitheater occupancy.

6. If a proposed development is located within a designated Geologic Hazard Special Study Area or an area with known earthquake hazards, at what point in the development process should a site-specific geologic investigation be completed? Shouldn’t those findings be available before major land-use decisions, rezonings, or development agreements are considered?

Like the traffic study, a geotechnical study will be a prerequisite to project plan approval. If surface faults are identified, the project plan will have to be adjusted to follow recommendations of the geotechnical study. Performing this study then having it reviewed by a consultant the city will hire will take months.